Skip to main content

Thermionic Valve Amplifier

I stumbled upon a source for some cool old stuff called Magic Eye tubes.  The shop is in Chelyabinsk Russia, called Tubes Store.

Here is a nice VU meter video:
http://tubes-store.com/product_info.php?cPath=31_59&products_id=5

While browsing there, I decided to make a little(!) audio amplifier to hook to my Mac, get a couple of Magic Eye tubes to use for a VU meter (blah) or robot eyes (yes!) and some Nixie tubes for a clock or digital read-out, or goodness knows what, so I ended up buying a handful of brand new old junk.

Skeleton of FR4 on a wood base - It sounds great!

Now the problem is getting high voltage transformers and capacitors that can handle >200 Volts.  Everything in my junk box is low voltage and will go pop, just like the weasel of yore.

When I built radios and avionics at Grinel, there was a huge 15 Kilowatt Klystron valve sitting in the store across the hallway - a relic from a previous radar project.  That thing was about 1 meter tall and the wooden floor of the room actually sagged under its weight.  The valves used in this project are ever so slightly smaller...

After a little bit of head scratching, I came up with this cool little thermionic valve audio amplifier design.  For fun, I added a 3 way tone control:


It is a pretty standard push-puller, using a miniature 6N21B dual triode valve at the front end and a pair of 6E6PE power tetrode valves at the back end (It is a rough drawing, but it gives the idea - I ended up using a full wave rectifier).  This push pull circuit should be able to deliver about 20 W RMS and will make a good lead guitar amplifier.

The first bipolar transistor audio amplifier I built when I was about 12 and the first song that blared forth was Money Honey, from the Bay City Rollers.  Yeah, I'm that old...

How Does a Valve Work?  

In the middle is a heating coil.  Around the coil, is a metal tube called the Cathode.  Around the Cathode is a wire grid, called... wait for it... drum roll... the Grid.  Around the grid is another metal tube called the Anode.  The plates are blackened to improve their ability to shed/absorb flying electrons.  The glass bulb is evacuated, thus enabling electrons to fly unimpeded from the Cathode to the Anode, which is powered at a high positive voltage of 150V or more.  The Grid is biassed negative w.r.t. the Cathode and controls the electron flow, hence the name Thermionic Valve.  To make the Grid 'negative', put a series resistor and bypass capacitor on the Cathode to bias it somewhere north of plus 20 Volt.

With a small signal on the grid, the valve can control a large electron flow between the Cathode and Anode, which makes an amplifier.  Therefore a valve and a MOSFET transistor work sorta kinda the same, except that a MOSFET doesn't need a heater or a vacuum.

For an output stage made from bipolar transistors, one can use NPN and PNP power transistors, but all valves are the same since nobody managed to make a positronic valve yet, so a transformer is required to make a complimentary output.  It is also required to transform the impedance down to drive a low ohmage speaker - about 6000:1.

The second audio amp I built was a monster - a 600 Watt RMS bipolar transistor bass guitar amp - and the first song that thundered out of that one at 2am at night was Tie Your Mother Down of Queen.  I don't want to know what the neighbours thought of it.

Due to the high voltages, I used big 2 W metal film resistors, except for R5, R8 and R20, which I made 10W wire wound.   Don't use carbon resistors in an audio amplifier - they are noisy.  Metal film only cost a few pennies more and they don't hiss.  The capacitors should all be 250V or higher rated, to keep them from going pop.

When I finally turned up the volume on this little tube amp, the first song that came out of the speaker from my Mac tuned to Antenna Bayern, was - wait for it - drum roll...  Music Was My First Love of John Miles - really!

Improvising and Bread Boarding

Now where on earth can I get transformers for the 6.3V heaters and 160 V anodes?  Thermionic valves are very forgiving - they don't blow or burn out easily, so the voltages and resistors used in a valve project need not be accurate - most anything goes, provided that the part voltage rating is high enough.  One could use an automotive ignition coil for the audio output transformer (10,000:1) and a couple of low voltage transformers back to back for the heater and high voltage power supply, but it turned out that there is a manufacturer of replica guitar amp transformers in Canada, Hammond Manufacturing, eh...

The prototype was built on an olde skool wooden bread board.

The Hammond classic audio output transformer should sound better than a car coil.  Well, I hope - at least it will look better:
http://www.hammondmfg.com/125a.htm
http://www.hammondmfg.com/300series.htm

and one can get high voltage electrolytic capacitors from Digikey:
http://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/EKXG351ELL101MM25S/565-1457-ND/755973

Next time I walk past a Pakistani trinket store down town, I'll pick up an old fashioned wooden box to put it in. I saw a replica His Master's Voice wind-up record player the other day - that store will have something.

There is also a manufacturor of new electron tubes for audio amplifiers, the Xpo-Pul (Reflektor) factory in Saratov, Russia:   http://rutubes.com/category/reflector-tube-saratov-russia/

Really BIG electron tubes and oscillators are made in China by Bejing Jenerator Co:

So, it is no problem to build a new old toy today, but it ain't cheap.  Shipping transformers and high voltage parts halfway around the world is expensive.  I guess my little amplifier will cost about $300 when it is all done.

Transformers

I finally ordered the transformers.  It turned out to be easiest to get them from Mouser and instead of getting a multi-winding valve amp power transformer, I got separate transformers for the heaters and anodes (as in the schematic!) - easier that way. Mouser does stock a Hammond Fender replica power transformer, but it is 115 V only - while I live in UAE with 240 V mains supply.

It is possible to build these toys without a mains transformer - by simply rectifying the mains directly, but then you are not protected against common mode spikes and the resulting circuit will be hot and dangerous.  Don't do that.  Rather shell out for the two mains transformers, since they are much cheaper than a visit to the undertaker.

I got a Hammond 185C230 for the anode voltage:

Primary 230 V:
Connect in series
.1, 6 = 230 V mains
2, .5 = Short

Secondary 115 V:
Connect in parallel
12, 8 = Short
.11, .7 = Short

Since the secondary was paralleled and not centre tapped as in the schematic above, I then built a four diode full wave rectifier instead.

A VPS12-2000 transformer is used for the heaters:

Primary:
Connect in series
.6, 1 = 230 V mains
5, .2 = Short

Secondary:
Connect in parallel
.12, .8 = short
11, 7 = short

The audio transformer I settled on is the Hammond 1750H:

Primary:
.Blue / Brown = 6600 Ohm
Red = Centre Tap

Secondary:
.Black, Brown = 8 Ohm

Note that you must never run a valve amp without a load - the output transformer will arc and destroy itself.  I mounted a large 10 Ohm 25 Watt resistor on the bread board next to the output transformer to use as a dummy load.

Let me say that again: Never run a valve amp without a load!

If the speaker is in a separate box, then you could put a CG590L 90 V gas arrestor from Littelfuse on the output transformer to try to protect it.

Note the separation and 90 degree rotation offset between the two mains transformers and the audio output transformer on the breadboard.  That is to reduce mains hum coupling into the audio output.

I'll get a 6 inch full range car speaker pair at Lulu or Carrefour and maybe stick it in an old fashioned wooden box from my new found Pakistani friend downtown.

Also, do put a fuse in the mains line.  I used a 150 mA, 600 V polyfuse, 600R150-RBZR and most important, solder a couple of 1 Megohm resistors on the outputs of the high voltage PSUs to bleed the capacitors when powered off, else you may be in for a surprise one day.  Do put a rubber bathroom carpet on the floor...

It is always a good idea to short out the PSU with a screwdriver before you touch anything - bleeding resistors or no.  It is better to burn a hole in a perfectly good screwdriver, than to end up on your backside on the floor - or in a wooden overcoat at the undertaker.

Valves

Both types of valves have 9 pins.  The power valve has a gap between pins 1 and 9 as usual.  Viewed from the bottom pin end, the number sequence runs clockwise.

The old yellowed Rusky data sheets are hilarious.

When I first met my wife (she is Slovak), I had a red hammer and sickle T-shirt (made in Honduras - where else?).  So she asked: "Where you get that shirt? You look like Russian athlete!".  Now I'm building toys from parts really made in ze olde CCCP, decades after everyone else stopped making them.  The commies were good at making things, but sometimes a bit slow in keeping up with advances.

One of our Czech friends remarked: The communists were good at building big machines to mine coal and iron ore, to make steel, to make big machines to mine coal and iron ore...

The 6E6PE tetrode valve pin-out is as follows:

1 - k
2 - g1
3 - k
4 - h
5 - h
6 - k
7 - a
9 - g2

The pre-amp miniature dual valve is funny and has a gap between pins 6 and 8, just to be confusing.

The two triodes have a shield between them - you have to ground it. So this is a nice, compact, low power design with only three glass tubes, but four valves. Because the double triode is physically small, the operating voltage is lower than normal at 'only' 100 V.  This works fine, since in a simple valve amplifier design, each stage is isolated from the other with a power line RC filter.  Of course, if you want to show off more glassware, then by all means, use two of the little tubes.

In this design, I drop the voltage from 160 V to 100 V using a 330 Ohm series resistor R8 and stabilize it with the capacitor C4.  This prevents voltage sags caused by the output stage, from feeding back into the input and reduces distortion.


The 6N21B miniature dual valve pin-out is as follows:

1 - k1
2 - s
3 - g1
4 - a1
5 - h
6 - k2
7 - no pin
8 - g2
9 - a2
10 - h

 

Terminology

When working with olde skool parts, one also comes across the olde skool terminology.  Hertz, becomes cycles, a mixer becomes heterodyning, feedback becomes regeneration, a capacitor becomes a condenser, an inductor becomes a coil and a diode becomes a cat's whisker, or a crystal - for auld lang syne.

Valve Sockets

One can still buy new octal sockets.  They are manufactured for relays.  However, all the tubes I got have 9 or more pins, so that is no help.  I could make a plan with some D-sub connector sockets - they look like they will fit - but the Tubes Store also has original ceramic sockets and they don't cost much.

You have to mount these things on a metal plate - and remember to ground it or you will get zapped sooner or later - likely sooner.  A cookie tin or bread pan is good, but do get an aluminium one, since steel is awfully hard to work by hand.  To make odd shaped cut outs, I use a Nibble Tool from Digikey:
http://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/12-1806-0000/GC395-ND/258502

The advantage of a nibbling tool is that it doesn't deform the sheet metal - it stays straight and flat - and you can cut any shape hole you need.  The disadvantage is that it is slow and painful to use.  Wrap some tape around the handles...

For the prototype, I mounted the valves and pots on scrap aluminium sheets, but for the final model I used copper clad FR4 PCB, since it is much easier to work, incredibly strong and doesn't warp when you abuse it with hand tools.  Using the copper as a ground plane, also eliminates about half the wires - another big advantage.  One can get FR4 in multiple colours nowadays, such as red, blue, green, black - even camouflage.   So your toys can look cheerful even when built in a simple way.

Note that FR1 and FR2 printed circuit board has made a comeback, thanks to cheap PCB milling machines (which gets worn out by the glass in FR4): https://www.sparkfun.com/categories/tags/fr1

It is much better to work at home with FR1, since the resulting dust doesn't make you itch like the fibreglass in FR4, which tends to pollute your whole workshop with white itch powder.  The disadvantage is that FR1 is not quite as strong and you need to be good with soldering, so you don't lift the copper.

The double triode presented a problem, since it doesn't fit in a socket.  It has long thin wires.


I soldered it into a 1 inch square circuit board, leaving some space for heat dissipation and fashioned the wires into little eyelet loops at the bottom so I can wire it up to the rest of the circuit in the same way as with tube sockets.  Time will tell whether this was a good idea or not - turns out it wasn't - I eventually soldered the tube into a 9 pin ceramic valve socket.

Terminal Strips and Turret Boards

Due to the high voltages, wired connections need to be kept millimeters apart.  These old fashioned high voltage solder tag strips are hard to find, but Digikey and Mouser do have them, if you know to search for 'turret boards'.


http://eu.mouser.com/_/?Keyword=turret+boards&FS=True




http://www.digikey.com/product-search/en/connectors-interconnects/terminal-strips-and-turret-boards/1442011?k=terminal&stock=1

For hooking the parts up, you need some 22 AWG tinned copper wire, which is unhelpfully named 'bus bar wire' by the vendors.  It is available in little 100 foot rolls.  Don't use 'magnet wire' - well, you could if you are a masochist.  Magnet wire is insulated with epoxy or nylon which is very hard to strip.

If you want it to look seriously retro, then you could use miniature rigid co-ax for the signals.  That will make it look like a steam engine. You can get rigid co-ax from Pasternack: https://www.pasternack.com/semirigid-0.141-50-ohm-coax-cable-tinned-aluminum-pe-sr402al-p.aspx

I'd recommend that you build the PSU first and when you are ready to test it, put a cardboard box over it, before turning the power on, to contain the mess if something would blow up.   When I was a teenager, I built a 600 Watt bipolar transistor bass guitar amp and had a very big capacitor (Cola can size) blow up in my face - it wasn't much fun - fortunately I was wearing glasses and I've been rather more careful ever since.

Grounding and Shielding

When you wire things up, always use the big capacitors as star points for power and ground - don't daisy chain.  That keeps the voltage sags and distortion down.

Also make a massive star bundle of about a dozen long thin earth wires that you can later use to ground all the metal parts, transformers and chassis and twist around sensitive wires leading to the volume and tone controls and gate of the first triode.   You don't have to use screened wire - just twist an earth wire around a signal to protect it, but if you want it to look more neat, use a thin coaxial cable such as RG316 and earth the shield at one end only - strip the plastic outer to make it more flexible and look more olde skool.  After the first triode, the signal is amplified enough that noise pickup won't be a problem any more, but you can still get feedback, causing howl round, so the more shielding, the better.

While the prototype sure looks messy, by tediously using a star grounding system throughout, I had no hum, no motorboating, no howling or squealing, no noise, just pure sound - purrfect - well, OK, until I moved the thing, which caused it to start howling - so I had to rewire it all with RG316 coax...

 No noise - Just pure audio.

Note: Disconnect the ground wire of your oscilloscope power lead.  If the scope is floating, then you cannot short things out with the ground clip and you can measure floating and differential signals directly.  I always get annoyed when someone takes my scope power leads and that idjit then ends up with a Darwin Award ungrounded power lead...

If you can hear mains hum when you turn the volume up (with no input signal), then you did not ground and shield the amplifier circuitry properly.  Some people build elaborate solid state DC supplies for the heaters; others trim the ground of the heater supply with a 'humdinger' circuit to cancel hum, but none of that is necessary.  If you build the thing on a copper clad FR4 ground plane, ground the transformers, use individual twisted pairs for the heaters (don't daisy chain) and shield all signal wires, then you will not have hum.  My amplifier is absolutely quiet - no hum and no hiss whatsoever.

The missus prolly won't like having a Carrefour breadboard full of hot and sizzling high voltage parts in the living room - so once it is working, then one got to unscrew the terminal strips and valve sockets, lift it off the bread board and re-install the unholy rat's nest into a fancy looking box, so make sure that you mount the sockets from the under side, unless you want to re-solder everything...

Once all is working again, clean with alcohol and spray the electronics (not the power resistors and tubes!) with V-66 or similar conformal coating to keep it from corroding and it will keep working and look nice for years.

BTW, I eventually kept the gizmo as an open skeleton construction, but stuck a sheet of clear acrylic to the top of the transformers to keep curious fingers out of the high voltage areas.

Bluetooth Audio

This is an old fashioned amplifier, but that doesn't mean it needs to be stuck completely in the past.  You can get little Bluetooth audio receivers on Ali Express for a Bob or two:
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32961053585.html



At first, I took the path of least effort and plugged in a USB wall wart for power and a little cable to the amplifier and it was working well enough.  Since it is a mono amplifier, I should wire the two BT audio outputs together through a pair of 100 Ohm resistors, but oldie radio stations are mono anyway:
http://www.1940sukradio.co.uk/bhfr/

Last week I felt bored and built a little 5 V power supply to hook the BT module up to the 6 V heater transformer.  That resulted in two interesting issues: First, a diode popped (I forgot that one end of the transformer is grounded!) and then the BT module would reboot every few minutes, which was just a wee little bit annoying in the middle of the music.

Who would like to hear: BEEBOOP!!! YOUR BLUETOOTH RADIO IS READY TO PAL!!! in a friendly and cultured female Chinese voice every five minutes?  It took me a long time to figure out where to put an additional 1000 uF capacitor, to convince the nice lady to be a little more discreet.

Now, I can finally put my amp anywhere, plug it into the wall and have some muzak.  It is funny having an iPhone play over a valve amplifier, but it sounds good!

Ye Olde Amplifier Sounds Best With Olde Muzak

My favourite oldies station to play over this new old amplifier, is probably Majestic Jukebox Radio https://www.majesticjukeboxradio.com

The British Home Front Radio is usually also good fun http://www.1940sukradio.co.uk/BHFR/

The US Megaton Cafe Radio is similar https://www.megatoncaferadio.com for those who prefer the other side of the pond.

This is the muzak my parents and grand parents grew up with and creates a good background ambience.

Postscript

Every day, about 100 people from around the globe look at this article.  I've been wondering how many actually end up building it, or something based on it.  If it is only 1%, then over the last 3 years, I have caused people to spend roughly $200,000 on this hobby.  I hope you can forgive me!


Have fun!

Herman

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Parasitic Quadrifilar Helical Antenna

This article was reprinted in OSCAR News, March 2018:  http://www.amsat-uk.org If you want to receive Satellite Weather Pictures , then you need a decent antenna, otherwise you will receive more noise than picture. For polar orbit satellites, one needs an antenna with a mushroom shaped radiation pattern .  It needs to have strong gain towards the horizon where the satellites are distant, less gain upwards where they are close and as little as possible downwards, which would be wasted and a source of noise.  Most satellites are spin stabilized and therefore the antenna also needs circular polarization, otherwise the received signal will flutter as the antennas rotate through nulls. The helical antenna, first proposed by Kraus in 1948, is the natural solution to circular polarized satellite communications.  It is a simple twisted wire - there seems to be nothing to it.  Various papers have been published on helix antennas, so the operation is pretty well understood. Therefore,

Patch Antenna Design with NEC2

The older free Numerical Electromagnetic Code version 2 (NEC2) from Lawrence Livermore Lab assumes an air dielectric.  This makes it hard (but not impossible) for a radio amateur to experiment with Printed Circuit Board Patch antennas and micro strip lines. Air Spaced Patch Antenna Radiation Pattern You could use the free ASAP simulation program , which handles thin dielectrics, you could shell out a few hundred Dollars for a copy of NEC4 , You could buy GEMACS if you live in the USA, or you could add distributed capacitors to a NEC2 model with LD cards (hook up one capacitor in the middle of each element.), but that is far too much money/trouble for most. More information on driving an array antenna can be found here: https://www.aeronetworks.ca/2019/03/driving-quad-patch-array-antenna.htm l Air Dielectric Patch   The obvious lazy solution is to accept the limitation and make an air dielectric patch antenna. An advantage of using air dielectric, is that the antenn

Weather Satellite Turnstile Antennas for the 2 meter Band

NEC2, 2 m band, 146 MHz, Yagi Turnstile Simulation and Build This article describes a Turnstile Antenna for the 2 meter band, 146 MHz amateur satcom, 137 MHz NOAA and Russian Meteor weather satellites.  Weather satellite reception is described here .  A quadrifilar helical antenna is described here .   Engineering, is the art of making what you need,  from what you can get. Radiation Pattern of the Three Element Yagi-Uda Antenna Once one combine and cross two Yagis, the pattern becomes distinctly twisted. The right hand polarization actually becomes visible in the radiation pattern plot, which I found really cool. Radiation Pattern of Six Element Turnstile Antenna Only a true RF Geek can appreciate the twisted invisible inner beauty of a herring bone antenna... Six Element Turnstile Antenna Essentially, it is three crosses on a stick.  The driven elements are broken in the middle at the drive points.  The other elements can go straight throug